Article Text

PDF

Traumatic brain injury after a motor vehicle accident: Fact or “fantasy”?
  1. D G E Caldicott,
  2. N Edwards
  1. Royal Adelaide Hospital, South Australia
  1. Dr Caldicott, Department of Emergency Medicine, Royal Adelaide Hospital, North Terrace, Adelaide, SA 5000, Australia (dcaldico{at}mail.rah.sa.gov.au)

Statistics from Altmetric.com

Gamma hydroxybutyrate (GHB) is a water soluble, naturally occurring, tetra-carbon molecule. It has intermittently found use as a hypnotic anaesthetic agent, in treatment for narcolepsy, as an anabolic agent, and more recently as a drug of abuse1–7 (also known as “fantasy”, “GBH”, etc (see box 1 ). Review of the literature refutes the suggestion that GHB is a safe “natural high”, with a number of fatalities from overdose now reported.8,9 Deaths occur from profound respiratory and cardiovascular depression.7–9 We report two cases of Fantasy overdose in association with a motor vehicle crash, the presenting symptoms of which prompted treating doctors to erroneously suspect serious intracranial pathology.

Box 1 Street synonyms for gamma hydroxybutyrate

Fantasy

Phantasy

Liquid ecstasy

Liquid gold

Liquid X

Cherry Meth

Soap

GBH

Case report

A 21 year old man and 20 year old woman were brought to the Trauma Unit of the Royal Adelaide Hospital after a motor vehicle crash.

The man was the restrained driver of a vehicle that had lost control and crashed into a stobie pole (see fig 1), at a speed in excess of 60 kph. There was at least 60 cm intrusion into the front passenger compartment. His GCS was estimated as 14 (E=4, V=4, M=6) at the scene, where he was aggressive and combative, bleeding from a 5 cm midline laceration to his forehead. On arrival, he remained uncooperative, and required restraint. Further examination showed abrasions to his right shoulder, with an underlying fractured clavicle. He underwent computed tomography of his head, cervical spine and abdomen, all of which were normal.

Figure 1

A stobie pole. Essentially two metal girders on either side of a concrete core, they were designed to support lines of electricity and communication to remote and rural southern Australia. Their longevity is inversely proportional to their contribution to road safety.

The woman was the restrained front seat passenger, who was allegedly asleep at the time of the accident. On arrival of the ambulance crew, her GCS was estimated as 11 (E=4, V=2, M=5). In transit, her level of consciousness deteriorated to a GCS of 6 (E=2, V=2, M=2), and she tolerated an oropharyngeal airway. She was endotracheally intubated for airway control on arrival in the emergency department. Examination revealed bilateral dilated and reactive pupils. She had an obvious “lap-belt” bruise across her lower abdomen, but without apparent other injury. After her intubation, she had a transient episode of bradycardia (50/ min), but maintained her blood pressure, with the bradycardia resolving spontaneously. She was taken for a CT scan of her head, cervical spine and abdomen, which were unremarkable other than an anterior crush fracture through the 10th thoracic vertebral body. She was admitted to the intensive care unit for observation overnight, and on weaning from sedation, rapidly regained consciousness.

Both patients subsequently admitted to having taken two “capfuls” of “fantasy” before the crash, with toxicological analysis of their urine by spectrophotometry, confirming the presence of GHB alone.

Discussion

GHB overdose is most often associated with the nightclub scene, and usually in the absence of associated trauma. Features of GHB are outlined in box 2 (A). The cases presented in this report demonstrate two important points. Firstly, in the context of trauma, concomitant GHB use can significantly blur the clinical presentation. GHB was almost certainly the cause of both patients diminished GCSs, and yet injuries incurred in the motor vehicle crash were originally thought responsible. Features that might cause suspicion of GHB use in an unconscious patient are outlined in box 2 (B). Our female patient had dilated pupils, the reason for which was never elucidated. It should be emphasised that the diagnosis of GHB overdose in the presence of trauma is always one of exclusion.

Box 2 (A) Pharmacological features of gamma hydroxybutyrate (GHB), with (B) features in the presentation of the unconscious patient that suggest GHB overdose

(A) PHARMACOLOGICAL FEATURES OF GAMMA HYDROXYBUTYRATE 7,15

White powder (sold in tablet or capsule form) or dissolved in water to form viscous clear fluid (sold by “capful”).

Soapy/salty taste often masked by addition of artificial flavouring.

Onset of action 20 minutes after oral ingestion.

Half life 20–30 minutes.

Metabolised via Krebs cycle to carbon dioxide with respiratory clearance.

Biochemical precursors gamma butyrolactone and 1,4 butanediol metabolised to GHB.

(B) FEATURES IN THE PRESENTATION OF THE UNCONSCIOUS PATIENT THAT SUGGEST GHB OVERDOSE.1–7

Historical features

History of previous/concurrent GHB use.

Attendance in the preceding six hours at a rave or night club

Features on examination

No evidence of head injury.

Equally reacting normal sized pupils.

Bizarre, athetoid posturing (“like a swimmer drowning”).

Diminished or fluctuating GCS, the latter especially on noxious stimulation.

Unexplained bradycardia, bradypnoea and/or apnoea

Features on investigation

Normal blood sugar level

Normal CT of the head

Secondly, we believe this to be the first reported case in which the drug has played a causative part in a potentially lethal motor vehicle crash. This may be merely a reflection of the increasing prevalence of the drug, but should serve notice that further episodes such as this are likely to occur. The potential hazards associated with GHB use and driving have been suggested.10 The day after presentation, the driver reported that despite driving on a road he used regularly, while under the influence of GHB, he had been completely disorientated in time and place.

GHB is an increasingly important drug of misuse, with serious and potentially lethal effects in overdose. Its danger is compounded by the mistakenly perceived “safety” of its use by the drug abusing community. It is taken as a euphoriant, but there is a narrow window between the quantity required to achieve the desired effect, and that which can cause dangerous and potentially lethal side effects.8,9 It has increasingly been associated with “date rape”.11 The intrinsic dangers of GHB misuse are already well described: it is perhaps surprising that it has taken so long for its secondary dangers, common to all sedating drugs of misuse, to become apparent. Legislation in the USA has recently been passed to make GHB and ketamine Schedule 1 drugs (that is, on a par with heroin and LSD).12 Biochemical precursors of GHB (gamma butyrolactone and 1,4-butanediol) are being marketed to subvert this legislation; their effects in overdose are almost identical to GHB.13,14 All three compounds are easily made from cheap and readily acquired household ingredients, with recipes accessible from the internet.15 Unchecked, there is unlikely to be any diminution in the use of this category of drugs in the foreseeable future, and physicians have a responsibility to highlight the dangers of GHB and its related compounds to both users and legislators alike.

Our institution is currently conducting a trial of the use of physostigmine (originally used for reversal of elective GHB anaesthesia16) as a reversal agent for GHB overdose. We have had promising results,17 with similar findings reported in the USA.18 It is possible that in trauma cases that have no apparent injury despite detailed physical examination and appropriate imaging physostigmine might have a role in reversing isolated GHB overdose.

Acknowledgments

Contributors

DC treated the patients, collated the information from the case notes, interviewed the patients, and performed the literature search. DC and NE co-wrote the manuscript and revisions. NE acts as guarantor for the paper.

References

View Abstract

Footnotes

  • Funding: none.

  • Conflicts of interest: none.

Request permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.