Article Text

PDF

Ultrasound by emergency physicians to detect abdominal aortic aneurysms: a UK case series
  1. A Walker1,
  2. J Brenchley2,
  3. J P Sloan1,
  4. M Lalanda1,
  5. H Venables3
  1. 1Department of Emergency Medicine, Leeds General Infirmary, Leeds, UK
  2. 2Department of Emergency Medicine, Barnsley District General Hospital, Barnsley, UK
  3. 3School of Healthcare Studies, University of Leeds, Leeds, UK
  1. Correspondence to:
 Dr J Brenchley
 Department of Emergency Medicine, Barnsley District General Hospital, Gawber Road, Barnsley S75 2EP, UK; jane.brenchleybdgh-tr.trent.nhs.uk

Abstract

Early identification of abdominal aortic aneurysms in some patients can be difficult and the diagnosis is missed in up to 30% of patients. Ultrasound cannot be used to identify a leak, but the presence of an aneurysm in an unstable patient is conclusive. With minimal training emergency physicians can easily identify the aorta and thus in the early phase of resuscitation an aneurysm can be confidently excluded. The purpose of the examination is not to delineate the extent of the aneurysm, but to identify those patients that will need emergency surgery. A series of patients presented to the department in an unstable condition with equivocal abdominal signs. An ultrasound scan in the resuscitation room by members of the emergency department revealed an aneurysm, which was enough to convince the vascular surgeons to take the patient straight to theatre with good results. In patients who are stable, computed tomography will continue to be used to evaluate the extent of the aneurysm and identify a leak.

  • aneurysm
  • ultrasound
  • AAA, abdominal aortic aneurysms
  • FAST, focused assessment with sonography in trauma

Statistics from Altmetric.com

Abdominal aortic aneurysms (AAA) present an important diagnostic challenge to emergency physicians. Although not a common condition, they are associated with significant mortality and early diagnosis is essential.

The diagnosis may be difficult in the emergency situation as patients may present with a non-specific history, and staff need a high index of suspicion to consider AAA in the differential diagnosis.1 Computed tomography is the gold standard investigation but can lead to a delay in definitive diagnosis and treatment (especially out of normal working hours), and transfer to scan may be associated with further risks or deterioration. An early ultrasound scan in the resuscitation phase may be the primary investigation of choice.

Some departments have protocols whereby patients who are suspected of having a AAA are transferred directly to a vascular surgery centre for definitive diagnosis and treatment.

This may entail inappropriate patients being transferred, or delays at the presenting hospital if inexperienced medical staff require senior backup to make this decision.

Ultrasonography is routinely used for screening and monitoring of aneurysm diameter2 and a limited ultrasound scan can reliably record the presence of an AAA.

If a normal aorta is clearly seen (as in most cases) an aneurysm can be confidently excluded. In the emergency setting no attempt is made to define the limits or relations of the aneurysm.

Ultrasound is not accurate in determining the presence of a leak from the aneurysm. In one study in emergency department patients, sonography was accurate in demonstrating presence or absence of aneurysm (98%), but its sensitivity for extraluminal blood was poor (4%).3

The combination of an aneurysm on ultrasound and an unstable patient is enough to warrant an emergency vascular surgery opinion.

PRINCIPLES OF EMERGENCY ULTRASOUND

Ultrasound use by emergency physicians is a focused examination to answer a single clinical question. In the assessment of trauma patients the purpose of the FAST (focused assessment with sonography in trauma) scan is to identify (rule in) the presence of free intraperitoneal fluid. In the context of trauma, this is assumed to be blood. Further management decisions are made according to the patient’s condition, but ultrasound adds valuable information in the early stages of assessment.

TRAINING

All middle grade and senior emergency physicians at Leeds General Infirmary had previously been trained to use ultrasound in the evaluation of blunt abdominal trauma (FAST). This entailed two sessions of both didactic training on the principles of ultrasound and the FAST protocol, and practical experience on normal volunteers and simulated patients (peritoneal dialysis patient volunteers). Emergency physicians were then required to record scans on 10 normal volunteers, these were reviewed by expert sonographers before accreditation as an emergency physician sonographer.

Data from all scanned patients are routinely recorded and suggest that there is little skill attrition with time. Rotational middle grade staff have been trained in the technique and on return to the department months later continue to exhibit adequate sonography skills.

Trained emergency physician sonographers underwent a further session of training by expert sonographers. This included a review of aortic anatomy, demonstrations of normal ultrasound appearances, and review of AAA ultrasound appearance. Once trained, the emergency AAA scan could be performed in less than five minutes. The appearances of the normal aorta scan view are shown in figure 1.

Figure 1

Normal anatomy (transverse). A, IVC; B, aorta; C, superior mesenteric artery; D, vertebral body; E, portal vein.

CASE SERIES

We present a series of patients who have attended our emergency department over a six month period and had a provisional diagnosis of AAA.

All patients underwent an ultrasound scan performed by emergency physicians, and after discussion with the vascular surgeons were immediately transferred to theatre.

Case 1

A 65 year old man bent down to lift a box and felt pain in his left hip. On presentation to hospital, he was haemodynamically stable with a palpable AAA, confirmed on ultrasound. Shortly thereafter he became cardiovascularly unstable and was transferred to theatre for repair of an infra-renal AAA. He made a good recovery and was well six months later.

Case 2

A 72 year old man presented with abdominal and back pain. While in the emergency department he collapsed and the ultrasound scan in the resuscitation room demonstrated a 7 cm aneurysm. He was transferred to the operating theatre for repair and was well three months later.

Case 3 (fig 2)

A 69 year old man collapsed with abdominal pain and was brought to the emergency department. An ultrasound scan in the resuscitation room revealed a large AAA. He was transferred to operating theatre and is alive and well one year later.

Case 4

A 67 year old man had experienced abdominal and back pain overnight, in association with diarrhoea. He was hypotensive on arrival and a 7 cm AAA was discovered when an emergency physician performed ultrasound in the resuscitation room. He was transferred to the operating theatre and survived the repair but died three days after operation.

Case 5 (fig 3)

A 58 year old man had colicky abdominal pain radiating to his back. He was haemodynamically stable and had an ultrasound scan performed as routine and to increase SHO awareness of the investigation. A 6 cm AAA was detected and he was referred for review by the vascular surgeons. Thirty minutes later he had a sudden haemodynamic collapse and was resuscitated and transferred straight to theatre.

These cases demonstrate the effectiveness of an emergency physician ultrasound scan in appropriate patients. Ultrasound has also been used successfully to exclude an AAA in hypotensive patients seen in the resuscitation room, and has therefore directed further investigations more appropriately. This is a small case series only looking at patients with positive scans. There is more work to be done evaluating the technique as rule out tool in these circumstances.

DISCUSSION

Some patients have a clear history and obvious clinical signs of an AAA. In these the diagnosis is not difficult. It has been clearly established that early diagnosis and surgery has significant survival benefits in these patients. An emergency physician performed ultrasound scan in the resuscitation room can be completed early while resuscitation is ongoing. Use of ultrasound by emergency physicians to exclude an AAA, is common in other countries.4

As increasing numbers of patients are transferred to a tertiary centre for surgery after acute presentation. A timely emergency physician performed ultrasound scan may expedite the decision to transfer.

Studies have shown that emergency physicians are accurate in the diagnosis of AAA on ultrasound. One study from Australia included patients in whom the diagnosis of AAA was suspected.5 Sixty eight scans were performed; 26 scans were positive, 40 scans yielded negative findings, and 2 scans were indeterminate. Scan interpretations were 100% accurate, compared with standard imaging or radiology review of the emergency ultrasound scan. In this study the primary benefit of ultrasonography was to exclude the diagnosis, but positive scans provided significant benefits for patients with AAA and led to improved management plans.

In our department, the use of ultrasound for AAA diagnosis followed naturally once the machine had been purchased by the department and emergency department staff had been trained in the FAST technique. The presence of an external aortic diameter of greater than 3 cm is considered diagnostic of an AAA, although increasing size increases the risk of rupture.

Initially there were concerns voiced by radiology colleagues about the use of ultrasound by non-radiologists. Most vascular surgeons however, are familiar with the ultrasound appearances of AAA, and a consensus decision on further management was reached in the cases presented. In patients with leaking AAAs, the speed of transfer to definitive care is a significant prognostic factor, rapid access to a senior vascular surgical opinion may be expedited by the emergency physician ultrasound scan.

We have shown that ultrasound skills for specific limited indications are easily learnt and retained. Support of the local radiology department is invaluable in introducing ultrasound into the emergency department. In our department all scans were initially reviewed by expert sonographers and although there was some disagreement about scan quality, none of the clinical conclusions drawn was invalid. Hard copies of all scans were obtained for inclusion in the patient’s notes and audit purposes. Ongoing review of a proportion of scans is worthwhile to monitor quality, this could be performed by an experienced emergency physician sonographer or radiology colleagues.

CONCLUSIONS

A limited ultrasound scan is a rapid screening test for detection of AAA in the resuscitation room. Emergency physicians competent in other ultrasound techniques can reliably perform the technique after a short training programme

REFERENCES

View Abstract

Request permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.