Article Text

PDF

Snake envenomation in a north Indian hospital
  1. N Sharma,
  2. S Chauhan,
  3. S Faruqi,
  4. P Bhat,
  5. S Varma
  1. Postgraduate Institute of Medical Education and Research, Chandigarh, India
  1. Correspondence to:
 Dr N Sharma
 Medicine, Postgraduate Institute of Medical Education and Research, Chandigarh 160012, India; nsharmaglide.net.in

Abstract

Objectives: To study the clinical profile of snake envenomation in a tertiary referral north Indian hospital.

Methods: Retrospective case note analysis of all cases of snakebite admitted to the medical emergency from January 1997 to December 2001.

Results: Of a total of 142 cases of snakebite there were 86 elapid bites presenting with neuroparalytic symptoms and 52 viper bites having haemostatic abnormalities. Some 60.6% of the cases of snakebite occurred when the patient was asleep. Urban to rural ratio was 1:4.7 and male to female ratio was 4.25:1. Median time to arrival at our hospital after the bite was nine hours and mean duration of hospital stay was eight days. Twenty seven cases had acute renal failure and 75% of all elapid bites required assisted ventilation. Seventeen of 119 patients who received antivenom had an adverse event. The average dose of antivenom was 51.2 vials for elapid bites and 31 vials for viper bites. Overall mortality rate was 3.5%.

Conclusion: Snakebites are common in the rural population of developing countries. There is a need to educate the public about the hazards of snakebite, early hospital referral, and treatment.

  • snakebite
  • elapids
  • viper
  • cobra
  • krait
  • neuroparalysis
  • acute renal failure
  • haemostatic abnormalities
  • antivenom

Statistics from Altmetric.com

Snakebite is a common medical emergency encountered in South Asia. In India alone 15 000 people of 20 000 bitten by snakes die every year.1 The principal effects of envenomation are on the nervous system, kidneys, heart, blood coagulability, vascular endothelium, and locally at the site of bite.1–3 The victims of snakebites are mainly of the rural population, who are bitten during field work and when sleeping outdoors.

The available data on epidemiology of snakebite from the Indian subcontinent are sparse because most snakebites occur in illiterate rural people who use witchcraft and traditional healers. Only cases of snakebite with severe envenomation reach the healthcare centres. This study was carried out to describe the arrival delays, clinical features, complications, and outcome of snakebites seen in a tertiary care hospital of north west India.

METHODS

This retrospective study was carried out at the Post Graduate Institute of Medical Education and Research, Chandigarh, India. This institute is a referral government hospital in north India where patients come from the states of Punjab, Haryana, Uttar Pradesh, and Himachal Pradesh. Patients included were those with:

  • the presence of fang marks.

  • presence of swelling, cellulitis, bleeding, blister formation at local site.

The records of snakebite victims from January 1997 to December 2001 were obtained from the records library of the hospital. This library uses the ICD-10 system for classification of diseases. The relevant details were entered on a form on which the site of bite and the type of treatment received before referral was recorded. Other details noted were the symptomatology and inhospital treatment. The resident physicians from the emergency team reported the data and cross checking of the data was carried out by two independent physicians. Neuroparalytic syndromes were defined as mild to moderate if the patient had muscle weakness and severe if ventilatory support was required. Haemostatic abnormalities were defined as bleeding from mucocutaneous sites and evident intravascular haemolysis. The time before the first dose of antivenom ws given after the snakebite, the amount of antivenom received, and adverse events were recorded. Adverse reactions to antivenom were; anaphylaxis, pyrexial reactions, and urticaria. Mortality was defined at necropsy and by death certificates. Statistical analysis of the data was performed using Instat software (Graphpad, San Diego, CA).

RESULTS

A total of 142 cases of snakebite were included in the study from the period January 1997 to December 2001. Figure 1 shows the month-wise distribution of snake bites. The number of cases of snakebite seen rose from 24 in 1997 to 39 cases in 2001. Most of the cases were young rural men with a mean age of 31.2 years (range 12–80 years). The urban to rural ratio was 1:4.7 and the male to female ratio was 4.25:1. Data were complete for 136 subjects.

The data depicted in figure 1 show that most of the cases occurred during the months of May to October. Some 60.6% of snakebites occurred at night when the patients were asleep and 23.1% during the afternoon siesta. The most frequently bitten site was the foot (38%). Figure 2 show the sites of the bite.

Figure 2

 Pie chart of the sites of snakebite.

Figures 3 and 4 show the clinical features. Neuroparalytic features, a hallmark of cobra and krait bites, were seen in 86 (60.6%) and haemostatic abnormalities attributable to viper bites in 52 (36.6%). There were no patients who had symptoms of both neuroparalysis and haemostatic dysfunction. Records of local treatment received were available in 88 patients. Seventy patients had received treatment before coming to the hospital. Among the forms of treatment received were a tourniquet tied in 16 patients, incision and drainage was performed in 14, and antivenom was given to 29. Forty patients were referred after antiseptic dressing of the bitten site. The median arrival time at the hospital after the bite was nine hours. The mean duration of hospital stay was eight days (range = 1–27 days). At our hospital, a total of 119 (83.8%) patients received equine polyvalent antivenom—one vial when reconstituted gives 10 ml. Antivenom was withheld in 23 cases in the absence of systemic envenomation. The mean dose antivenom given for neuroparalytic snakebite was 51.2 vials (range = 5–190 vials) and 32 vials (range = 1–130 vials) for viper bites. Of the 119 patients that received antivenom, 17 patients had an adverse reaction to antivenom (anaphylaxis (two), pyrexial reaction (6), urticaria (9)).

Figure 4

 Pie chart showing symptoms of viper bites in 52 cases.

Of 86 patients with neuroparalytic symptoms, 65 (75.6%) required assisted ventilation (for mean 52.8 hours). Of the 52 patients with viper bites, 39 (75%) patients had acute renal failure and of these 33 (84.6%) required dialysis. Five patients died giving a mortality rate of 3.5%. Two patients died of pulmonary oedema and one each because of acute respiratory distress syndrome, cortical venous thrombosis, and disseminated intravascular coagulation.

DISCUSSION

In India, the poisonous snakes belong to the elapid family of the cobra and krait and the viper family of the Russel’s viper and the saw scaled viper. Envenomation attributable to elapid bites causes paralysis of the ocular, bulbar, and limb girdle muscles. Viper bites mainly cause bleeding from mucocutaneous sites, haemolysis, acute renal failure, and occasionally shock.1

Snakebites are usually seen in people of rural areas, construction labourers, and farmers working in fields or sleeping outdoors. In this study most (82.4%) of the snakebites occurred in people from rural areas. In concordance with the earlier reports, more snakebites occurred at night time (60.6%).2 The exposed parts of the body, mainly the hands and feet were the sites bitten in 72.5% cases. Most bites occurred during sleep (71%) and in people engaged in manual labour in the fields (23.2%).

Most human snakebites occur during the monsoon season because of flooding of the habitat of snakes and their prey. It is the life cycle of the natural prey of these reptiles that govern contact with humans. The breeding habits of frogs closely follow the monsoons and rats and mice are always in close proximity to human dwellings. In our study there was a higher incidence of snakebites during the monsoon season. From another south Indian study snakebites abound during the months of October to December (33%) and May to July (67%).3

Treatment for snakebite is care of the bitten site and antivenom. Seventy two of our patients had received local treatment of the bitten site—that is, tourniquet, incision and drainage, and indigenous herbal medicines. These practices are not currently recommended in the treatment of snake envenomations.4 The median arrival time after the snakebite was nine hours. A prolonged arrival delay was seen in patients presenting with acute renal failure to this hospital. This can be explained on a geographical basis as all patients who developed acute renal failure came from the state of Himachal Pradesh, where access to villages by common modes of transport is still rudimentary. This delay in arrival can also be attributed to a lack of awareness of the hazards of snakebite, an unrelenting belief in the traditional system of medicines, and a lack of proper primary healthcare facilities.

Most snakebites in our study were neuroparalytic (60.6%) followed by bites causing haemostatic dysfunction (36.6%). The neuroparalytic symptoms seen were; in descending order ptosis, respiratory muscle involvement, oculobulbar weakness, and limb weakness (fig 1). The reported incidence of neurological symptoms from two Sri Lankan studies on neuroparalytic snakebites was ptosis in 70%–85%, respiratory muscle weakness in 18%–45%, ophthalmoplegia in 53%–75%, and limb weakness in 27%–54% respectively.5,6

Of 52 patients presenting with haemostatic abnormalities, bleeding from the vipers bites was most frequent followed by intravascular haemolysis and haematuria. In other studies, haemorrhagic syndromes after snakebites have occurred in 47.8%–90%.7,8 This variation in haemorrhagic manifestations can be explained by the subspecies differences of snake venoms.

Antivenom was given to 119 patients only. Although the dose of antivenom is not yet fixed, the indications are well known.8 The mean dose of antivenom used was 51.2 vials for elapid bites and 31 vials for viper bites. Adverse reactions to antivenom were seen in 14.2%, but there were no deaths. The death rate in our study was 3.5% and compares well with the death rate from other studies across India.2,3,7

In conclusion, snakebite mainly afflicts the rural men of developing countries. Availability of antivenom at primary healthcare centres and rapid transportation facilities may change the morbidity associated with snakebites. There is an urgent need to educate the rural population about the hazards and treatment of snakebites. Also, randomised controlled trials are needed to investigate the issue of rationale of antivenom treatment.

Figure 1

 Pie chart of the month-wise distribution of snakebites.

Figure 3

 Pie chart showing symptoms of neuroparalytic snakebites in 86 cases.

REFERENCES

View Abstract

Request permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.