Table 5

Author, date and countryPatient groupStudy type (level of evidence)OutcomesKey ResultsStudy weaknesses
Donegan MF et al, 1980, USA10 ventilated comatosed patients on ICU. IV lignocaine 1.5 mg/kg v N/SalineDouble blind PRCTChange in ICP on suctioningLignocaine attenuated rise in ICPSmall numbers
Patients not paralysed
White PF et al, 1982, USA15 comatosed patients with diffuse axonal injury on ICU. Compared response to suction with:RCTChange in baseline ICPReduced with lidocaine and thiopentoneSmall numbers
Unblinded
Change in ICP on suctioningNo effectQuestionable randomisation
Yano M et al, 1986,USA9 patients with severe head injury (GCS<8). All patients had mild cranial high BP. All ventilatedRCT compared response on suctioning. IV lignocaine v intratracheal lignocaine. Readings at 1, 3, 5, 10, 15 minChange in baseline ICPNo change in baseline ICPUnblinded
Small numbers
Change in ICP on suctioningBoth methods reduced ICPPatients not paralysed
Comparison of routesIntratracheal route more effective