Article Text

Download PDFPDF

Ultrasound to detect haemothorax after chest injury
  1. Kirsty McEwan, Medical Student,
  2. Peter Thompson, Consultant
  1. Guy, Kings and St Thomas’ Medical School, London, UK

    Abstract

    A short cut review was carried out to establish whether ultrasonography is as sensitive and specific as chest x ray or computed tomography (CT) scan in detecting haemothorax after chest trauma. Thirty-nine papers were found using the reported searches, of which six presented the best evidence to answer the clinical question. The author, date and country of publication, patient group studied, study type, relevant outcomes, results and study weaknesses of these best papers are shown in table 3. It is concluded that ultrasonography is more sensitive and as specific as chest x ray at detecting haemothorax in patients with chest trauma.

    View Full Text

    Statistics from Altmetric.com

    Report by Kirsty McEwan, Medical StudentChecked by Peter Thompson, ConsultantGuy, Kings and St Thomas’ Medical School, London, UK

    Three-part question

    [In adults with thoracic trauma] does [emergency department ultrasonography have better clinical utility than chest x ray] at [diagnosing haemothorax]?

    Clinical scenario

    A patient arrives in the emergency department after suffering thoracic trauma. A member of the team suggests using ultrasound to search for the presence of haemothorax, as an extension of the usual FAST assessment. You wonder how accurate the ultrasound would be compared to either the usual initial supine chest x ray or to a CT scan which could be performed later in the patient’s assessment.

    Search strategies

    Medline 1966 to present (accessed 29 May 2007) using the OVID interface: [thorax.mp or thoraxic.mp or thoracic.mp or emergancy.mp or chest.mp or pulmonary diseases.mp or thoracic lesions.mp or chest disease.mp]AND [radiography.mp or diagnosis/ or diagnosis, computer assisted/ or diagnosis, differential/ or “diagnostic techniques and procedures”/ or diagnostic imaging/ or radiography or radiography, thoracic/ or tomography, x-ray/ or ultrasonography/ or diagnostic techniques, cardiovascular/ or diagnostic techniques, respiratory system/ or diagnostic tests, routine/ or realy diagnosis or computed tomography.mp or CT.mp or thoracic CT.mp] AND [ultrasound.mp or ultrasonography.mp or explode ultrasonography/ or sonography.mp or radiological diagnosis.mp or ultrasonographic.mp or thoracic radiological procedures.mp or emergency ultrasound.mp or transthoracic ultrasound.mp or thoracic ultrasound.mp] AND [Hemathorax.mp or hemothorax.mp or haemathorax.mp or haemothorax.mp or traumatic effusion.mp].

    The Cochrane Library Issue 2 2007: (hemothorax):ti,ab,kw OR (haemothorax):ti,ab,kw

    Outcome

    Altogether 39 papers were found in Medline, of which 34 were irrelevant or of insufficient quality. Twenty-five papers were found in Cochrane—the only relevant paper had already been found in Medline. A further paper was found by scanning the references of relevant papers. All relevant papers are summarised in table 3.

    Table 3

    Comments

    Ultrasound is a sensitive, specific and accurate technique for detecting haemothorax in thoracic trauma patients. CT does detect some haemothoraces not seen on ultrasound; however, in a clinical situation, the two methods are performed on different patient populations and so are not directly comparable. The most clinically relevant diagnostic imaging method with which to compare ultrasound is the supine chest radiograph as they both are performed in the initial assessment of the patient. When compared directly to the supine chest x ray, ultrasound is shown to be more specific at detecting the presence of the haemothorax and is at least as specific and accurate. It also has the added advantage of being able to be performed in much less time, making it a useful diagnostic tool for the early diagnosis of haemothorax. However, it cannot replace the chest x ray as many other injuries can be shown on the chest x ray that cannot be demonstrated by ultrasound.

    CLINICAL BOTTOM LINE

    Ultrasound is a sensitive, specific and accurate method to detect the presence of haemothorax in trauma patients. It cannot, however, replace chest radiography because there is additional information on the x ray that ultrasound cannot provide.

    Report by Kirsty McEwan, Medical StudentChecked by Peter Thompson, ConsultantGuy, Kings and St Thomas’ Medical School, London, UK

    References

    View Abstract

    Request Permissions

    If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.