Table 1

Characteristics of included studies on Australasian Triage System, Canadian Acuity and Triage Scale (CTAS), Emergency Severity Index (ESI) and Manchester Triage System (MTS)

AuthorYearCountryTarget triage systemsPopulationsSample sizeSites (n)Design
Wuerz42 2000USAESIAdult4932Prospective
Wuerz43 2001USAESIAdult88552Retrospective
Wuerz53 2001USAESIAdult2021Retrospective
Jiménez26 2003AndorraCTASAdult /paediatric32 2611Retrospective
Eitel15 2003USAESI V.2Adult/paediatric10427Prospective
Bergeron47 2004CanadaCTASPaediatric551Prospective
Tanabe35 2004USAESI V.3NS4031Retrospective
Tanabe36 2004USAESI V.3NS4031Retrospective
Gouin18 2005CanadaCTASPaediatric5371Prospective
Baumann11 2005USAESI V.3Paediatric5101Retrospective
Dong14 2005CanadaCTASNS7221Prospective
Chi48 2006TaiwanESI, TTSAdult31721Prospective
Roukema32 2006NetherlandsMTSPaediatric10651Retrospective
Worster41 2006CanadaCTAS, ESI V.3NS4862Prospective
Baumann12 2007USAESI V.3Geriatric9291Retrospective
Dong13 2007CanadaCTASNS29 3461Prospective
Elshove-Bolk17 2007NorwayESIAdult18321Prospective
van Veen40 2008NetherlandsMTSPaediatric16 7352Prospective
van der Wulp39 2008NetherlandsMTSNS502Prospective
Ma10 2008CanadaCTASPaediatric16181Retrospective
van der Wulp38 2009NetherlandsESI, MTSNS37 974/34 2584Retrospective
Travers37 2009USAESI V.4Paediatric10005Prospective
Olofsson29 2009SwedenMTSAdult/paediatric10277Prospective
Gravel22 2009CanadaCTASPaediatric58 5291Retrospective
Martins45 2009PortugalMTSAdult316 6221Retrospective
Ng28 2010TaiwanCTAS, TTSAdult18513Prospective
Platts-Mills31 2010USAESIGeriatric7821Retrospective
van der Wulp54 20102010ESIAdult5841Prospective
Storm-Versloot34 2011NetherlandsMTS, ESI, ISSAdult/paediatric9001Prospective
Grossmann24 2011SwitzerlandESI V.4NS21141Prospective
Elkum16 2011KuwaitCTASAdult/paediatric12061Retrospective
Pinto30 2012BrazilMTSAdult/paediatric3001Prospective
Grossmann25 2012SwitzerlandESIGeriatric8191Prospective
Lee27 2012South KoreaCTASGeriatric19031Retrospective
Gravel21 2012CanadaCTASPaediatric15649Prospective
Green23 2012USAESI V.4Paediatric7801Retrospective
van Veen49 2012NetherlandsMTS, modified MTSPaediatric11 2102Prospective
Gravel20 2013CanadaCTASPaediatric550 94012Retrospective
Santos44 2013PortugalMTSNS24 7211Prospective
Al-Hindi51 2014Saudi ArabiaCTASPaediatric30141Prospective
Graff19 2014GermanyMTSNS45 4691Retrospective
Seiger33 2014Netherlands, UK, PortugalMTS V.1 and 2Paediatric60 7354Prospective
Guedes52 2015BrazilMTSAdult5771Prospective
Hong9 2015USAESIAdult3101Prospective
Ruipérez46 2015SpainESINS4101Prospective
Steiner50 2016SwitzerlandMTSAdult24071Prospective
  • ISS, informally structured triage system; NS, not stated; TTS, Taiwan Triage and Acuity Scale.