Table 1

Top 35 PREDICT research priorities (Questions appearing in bold appear top 10 of the Delphi process)

Hanlon priority (HPP score)Research questionsDelphi priority
(Delphi score)
1 (164) In children with severe asthma, does a specific intravenous agent compared with another intravenous agent (or placebo) result in improved outcomes? 4 (5.26)
2 (149)In well-looking infants aged 3–6 months with a urinary tract infection, is treatment with intravenous antibiotics compared with oral antibiotics associated with improved clinical outcomes? 14 (4.9)
3 (148) In children with severe asthma, does the early use of non-invasive respiratory support compared with standard care shorten the duration of hospitalisation? 6 (5.18)
4 (147) What is the sensitivity and specificity of the high-quality paediatric cervical spine clinical decision rules when applied to a single population of consecutive children presenting to the ED with cervical spine injury in Australasia? 8 (5.11)
5 (144) Does the use of a preintubation aid or checklist for emergency intubation improve paediatric intubation outcomes? 10 (5)
5 (144)In children presenting to the ED with an acute limp, can a combination of clinical features and/or investigations accurately differentiate septic arthritis/osteomyelitis from transient synovitis? 12 (4.96)
7 (138)In children presenting to the ED with abdominal pain, can a combination of clinical features and/or investigations accurately predict the need for surgical admission or intervention? 23  (4.64)
8 (134)In children presenting to the ED with presumed sepsis, or other need for volume resuscitation, does the use of a balanced isotonic solution compared with normal saline improve outcome?20 (4.69)
8 (134) In children presenting to the ED with presumed sepsis, does low-volume compared with high-volume fluid resuscitation improve outcome? 2 (5.28)
10 (132) In children who require emergency intubation, does the use of high flow nasal oxygenation during intubation attempts, compared with standard practice, improve outcome during and postintubation? 1 (5.37)
11 (130)In children undergoing sedation in an ED, what is the effectiveness and/or complication rate of various sedation agents commonly used? 16 (4.86)
12 (129)In children who present to the ED with sepsis, does the use of a protocol to guide care compared with no protocol to guide care improve outcomes? 13 (4.94)
13 (128) In paediatric patients who sustain blunt trauma with haemodynamic instability, does early tranexamic acid 15 mg/kg compared with placebo improve mortality and reduce morbidity? 9 (5.02)
14 (125)In children with greenstick fractures or Salter-Harris type 2 fractures of the distal radius or ulna, does the use of wrist splints compared with full POP lead to equivalent clinical outcomes? 18 (4.83)
15 (123) In children presenting with traumatic neck pain, does cervical spine CT scan compared with cervical spine plain films diagnose more clinically important cervical spine injuries? 2 (5.28)
16 (120) In children presenting to the ED with presumed sepsis, does early compared with late vasopressor therapy improve outcomes? 5 (5.22)
17 (119)In children presenting to the ED with suspected intussusception, pneumonia, appendicitis or a painful hip, does the use of bedside ultrasound result in improved clinical outcomes? 15 (4.89)
18 (117)In children who require minor fracture manipulation in the ED, is the use of nitrous oxide + intranasal fentanyl as effective as the use of ketamine? 19 (4.72)
19 (115)In a well-looking neonate with a normal urine test, lumbar puncture, and CXR, what is the role of intravenous antibiotics compared with no intravenous antibiotics while awaiting cultures? 17 (4.84)
19 (115)In infants who present to the ED with bronchiolitis, does the use of nasal bulb suction and/or normal saline drops compared with no suction and/or normal saline drops reduce admission rates? 32 (3.99)
21 (108)In unvaccinated children attending the ED, does an ED-based brief intervention increase the uptake of immunisations? 33 (3.79)
22 (106)In children who present to the ED with headache thought to be due to migraine, who have failed oral therapy, which intravenous therapy is the most effective treatment for their headache? 24 (4.57)
23 (103)In children presenting with suspected neck injury, does the application of a cervical collar compared with no cervical collar change the incidence of cervical spinal cord injury? 11 (4.99)
24 (97)In children presenting with a nail bed laceration, does a nail bed repair compared with conservative management change cosmetic outcome? 21 (4.68)
25 (90)In children presenting to the ED with suspected non-surgical abdominal pain, which analgesic options are most useful? 31 (4.01)
26 (88)Do children who present to a mixed ED compared with a paediatric ED have a difference in clinical outcome? 27 (4.38)
27 (84)In children presenting with facial trauma, does CT compared with plain films diagnose more clinically important facial fractures? 29 (4.33)
27 (84)Does immediate debriefing of critical events for emergency teams improve outcomes for the staff? 26 (4.4)
29 (81)In children with an acute exacerbation of asthma, can demographic or clinical features be used to predict timing of successful discharge? 33 (3.79)
30 (78) In medical staff working in a paediatric ED, what are the most effective interventions to reduce cognitive errors (errors in medical reasoning and decision making)? 6 (5.18)
31 (72)In children in cardiorespiratory arrest, does the use of a circulation airway breathing approach to initial management, compared with the use of an airway breathing circulation approach to initial management, change outcomes? 30 (4.09)
32 (61)In children in cardiorespiratory arrest, does the use of epinephrine compared with no use of epinephrine change outcomes? 25 (4.43)
32 (61)In children in ventricular fibrillation or pulseless ventricular tachycardia, does a specific energy dose or regimen of energy doses for the initial and/or subsequent defibrillation attempt(s), compared with 2–4 J/kg, change outcomes? 35 (3.58)
34 (53)In children presenting with facial lacerations, does primary suture closure in the ED compared with primary suture closure in theatre change cosmetic outcome? 28 (4.36)
35 (47)What are the drivers for paediatric patients attending an ED rather than primary care? 21 (4.68)
  • HPP, Hanlon Process of Prioritisation; PREDICT, Paediatric Research in Emergency Departments International Collaborative.