Table 1

Systematic mixed studies review (SMSR) eligibility criteria for the inclusion and exclusion of studies

Studies were included if:Studies were excluded if:
  • Patient experiences in the ED were outlined in the study aims/ objectives (or)

  • Study authors distinguished between the concepts of patient experience and patient satisfaction, and identified that their focus was on patient experience (or)

  • Survey instruments were patient experience surveys or patient-reported experience measures (or)

  • Survey instruments were developed with the intention of capturing patient experiences

  • Participants were adults (the legal age of adulthood differs internationally and across contexts, so we accepted study authors’ definition of adulthood)

  • Published between 1 January 2001 (publication year of the Crossing the Quality Chasm report)S31 and 16 September 2019

  • Published in English

  • Published in peer-reviewed journals

  • Primary research

  • Patient satisfaction or patient expectation was outlined in the study aims/ objectives (or)

  • Survey instruments were developed with the intention of capturing patient satisfaction

  • Studies were conducted in settings other than the ED (eg, inpatient, prehospital, outpatient)

  • Patients were children, adolescents or young adults (as defined by study authors)

  • Patient experience data was proxy-reported (eg, carer on behalf of a patient) or was unable to be extracted independently of proxy-reported data

  • Presented literature reviews, metareviews or quality improvement activities