Abstract
Progress in medicine and the subsequent extension of health coverage has meant that health expenditure has increased sharply in Western countries. In the United States, this rise was precipitated in the 1980s, compounded by an increase in drug consumption which prompted the government to re-examine its financial support to care delivery, most notably in hospital care and emergencies services. In California for example, 50 emergency service providers were closed between 1990 and 2000, and nine in 1999–2000 alone. In that State, only 355 hospitals (out of 568) have maintained emergency services departments (Darves, WebMB, 2001). Reforming hospital Emergency Department (ED) operations requires caution not only because the media pay a lot of attention to ED operations, but also because it raises ethical issues: this became more apparent with the enactment of the EMTALA which stipulates that federally funded hospitals are required to give emergency aid in order to “stabilize” a patient suffering from an “emergency medical condition” before discharging or transferring that patient to another facility. While in essence the law aims to preserve patient access to care, physicians assert that the EMTALA leads to more patients seeking care for non-urgent conditions in EDs (GAO, Report to Congressional Committees, 2001), leading to overcrowding, delayed care for patients with true emergency needs, and forcing hospitals to divert ambulances to other facilities resulting in further delays in urgent care. Also, fewer physicians are willing to be on-call in emergency departments because the EMTALA law requires on-call physicians to provide uncompensated care. Thus there is a need to find a balance between appropriate care to be provided to ED patients, and low costs since uncompensated care is not covered by state or federal funds. This concerns, first and foremost, hospitals that provide a greater amount of uncompensated care (e.g. hospitals serving communities with a higher population of illegal immigrants). Looking at the intrinsic causes of high ED costs, the paper first explains why costs of care provided in EDs are high, and look at a major cause of high ED costs: overcrowding and ED users’ characteristics. This is followed by a discussion on a much-debated factor: the use of EDs for non-emergency conditions, a practice which has often been accused of disproportionately raising costs. We look at various mechanisms used either to divert or prevent the patient from using ED: these include triage services; and the role of HMOs in the ED chain of care: though the US government has increasingly relied on Managed Care organizations to contain costs (e.g. Medicaid and Medicare Managed Care), do HMOs make a difference when it comes to ED costs? Of particular interest is the family physician acting as a gatekeeper, and the legislation that was enacted to protect those who bypass the referral system. We then look at the other end of the ED chain (i.e. the recipient): the financial responsibility of ED users has increased. Alternative providers such as walk-in clinics are increasingly common. EDs also attempt to reengineer their operations to curb costs. While the data are mostly applicable to a private health care system (e.g. the US), the article, using a critical assessment of the existing literature, has implications for other EDs generally, wherever they operate, since every ED faces similar funding problems.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Bailey, T. M., Topham, T. M., Wantz, S., et al. (1997). Laboratory process improvement through point-of-care testing. The Joint Communication Journal on Quality Improvement, 23, 362–380.
Baker, L. C., & Baker, L. S. (1994). Excess cost of emergency department visits for non-urgent care. Health Affairs, 13(5), 162–171.
Bamezai, A., Melnick, G., & Nawathe, A. (2005). The cost of an emergency department visit and its relationship to emergency department volume. Annals of Emergency Medicine, 45(5), 483–490.
Barber, J. W., King, W. D., Monroe, K. W., & Nichols, M. H. (2000). Evaluation of emergency department referrals by telephone triage. Pediatrics, 105(4 Pt.1), 819–821.
Bolton, M. B., Tilley, B. C., Kuder, J., Reeves, T., & Schultz, L. R. (1991). The costs and effectiveness of an education program for adults who have asthma. Journal of General Internal Medicine, 6, 401–407.
Brandt, C. P., Coffee, T., Yurko, L., Yowler, C. J., & Fratianne, R. B. (2000). Triage of minor burn wounds :avoiding the emergency department. The Journal of Burn Care Rehabilitation, 21(Pt.1), 26–28.
Braun, R., et al. (1995). Utilization of emergency medical services by homeless adults in San Francisco: Effects of social demographic factors. AHSR FHSR. Annual Meeting Abstract Book, 12, 114.
Brown, L. C. (2004). Call panels and the EMTALA final rule: What’s next for providers? Journal of Health Care Compliance, 16(1), 14–17.
Catalano, R. A., Coffman, J. M., Bloom, J. R., Ma, Y., & Kang, S. H. (2005). The impact of capitated financing on psychiatric emergency services. Psychiatric Services, 56(6), 685–690.
Caterino, J. M., Holliman, C. J., & Kunsleman, A. R. (2000). Underestimation of case severity by emergency department patients: Implications for managed care. The American Journal of Emergency Medicine, 18, 254–256.
Chin, N. P., Goepp, J. G., Malia, T., Harris, L., & Poordabbagh, A. (2006). Nonurgent use of a pediatric emergency department: A preliminary qualitative study. Pediatric Emergency Care, 22(1), 22–27.
Chovan, T., & Yoo, H. (2005). Health savings accounts off to a fast start in the individual market. Washington: America’s Health Insurance Plans.
Cooke, M. W., Higgins, J., & Kidd, P. (2003). Use of emergency observation and assessment wards: A systematic literature review. Emergency Medicine Journal, 20(2), 138–142.
Coopers & Lybrand. (1998). Estimated costs of selected consumer protection proposals: A cost analysis of the president’s advisory commission’s consumer bill of rights, responsibilities and the Patient Access to Responsible Care Act (PARCA). Menlo Park, CA: Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation.
Darves, B. (2001). California Medical Association reports cites steep ED financial losses, Resource Shortages. WebMB. Jan 22.
Davis, J., Kuhns, R., & Watson, D. J. (2004). Evaluating emergency medical services: Controlling the rising cost of saving lives. Journal of Health and Human Services Administration, 26(4), 485–512.
Derlet, R. W., & Richards, J. R. (2002). Emergency department overcrowding in Florida, New York, and Texas. South Medical Journal, 95(8), 846–849.
Derlet, R. W., Kinser, D., Ray, L., Hamilton, B., & McKenzie, J. (1995). Prospective identification and triage of emergency patients out of an emergency department: A 5-year study. Annals of Emergency Medicine, 25(2), 215–223.
Fermann, G. J., & Joe Suyama, J. (2002). Clinical laboratory in emergency medicine point of care testing in the emergency department. The Journal of Emergency Medicine, 22(4), 393–404.
Franco, S. M., Mitchell, C. K., & Buzon, R. M. (1997). Primary care physician access and gatekeeping: A key to reducing emergency department use. Clinical Pediatrics (Phila), 36(2), 63–68.
GAO. EMERGENCY CARE EMTALA. (2001). Implementation and enforcement issues. Report to Congressional Committees. United States General Accounting Office.
Gerbert, B., Wolff, M., Tschann, J. M., McPhee, S. J., Caspers, N. M., Martin, M. J., & Saulovich, A. (1997). Activating patients to practice skin cancer prevention: Response to mailed materials from physicians versus HMOs. American Journal of Preventive Medicine, 13(3), 214–220.
Goldman, L. (1995). Using prediction models and cost-effectiveness analysis to improve clinical decisions: Emergency department patients with acute chest pain. Proceedings of the Association of American Physisians, 107(3), 329–333.
Grannemann, T. W., Brown, R. S., & Pauly, M. V. (1986). Estimating hospital costs: A multiple-output analysis. Journal of Health Economics, 5, 107–127.
Gresenz, C. R., & Studdert, D. M. (2004). Disputes between over coverage of emergency department services: A study of two health maintenance organizations. Annals of Emergency Medicine, 43, 155–162.
Gresenz, C. R., Studdert, D. M., Campbell, N., et al. (2002). Patients in conflict with managed care: A profile of enrollee appeals of benefits denials in two HMOs. Health Affairs, 21(4), 189–196.
Halfon, N., et al (1996). Routine emergency department use for sick care by children in the United States. Pediatrics, 98(1), 28–34.
Ho, F. N., O’Donnell, K. A., & Chen, Y. J. (1998). Switching HMO providers. Dissatisfaction with emergency access cited as the primary reason for disenrollment. Marketing Health Services, 18(1), 23–27.
Hodge, D. (1999). Managed care and the pediatric emergency department. Pediatric Clinics of North America, 46(6), 1329–1340.
Hoffman, B. (2006). Emergency rooms: The reluctant safety net. In R. A. Stevens, C. E. Rosenberg, & L. R. Burns (Eds.), History and health policy in the United States. Putting the past back in (pp. 250–273). New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press.
Hsu, J., Price, M., Brand, R., Ray, G. T., Fireman, B., Newhouse, J. P., & Selby, J. V. (2006). Cost-sharing for emergency care and unfavorable clinical events: Findings from the safety and financial ramifications of ED copayments study. Health Services Research, 41(5), 1801–1820.
Hsu, J., Reed, M., Brand, R., Fireman, B., Newhouse, J. P., & Selby, J. V. (2004). Cost-sharing: Patient knowledge and effects on seeking emergency department care. Medical Care, 42(3), 290–296.
Irvin, C. B., & Fox, J. M. (2000). Effect of a State definition of an “emergency medical condition” legislation on medicaid managed care organization reimbursement. Annals of Emergency Medicine, 35, 283–286.
Kapur, K., Gresenz, C. R., & Studdert, D. M. (2003). Managing care: Utilization review in action at two capitated medical groups. Health Affairs (Millwood), 22, 275–282.
Kennedy, J., Rhodes, K., Walls, C. R., & Asplin, B. R. (2004). Access to emergency care: Restricted by long waiting times and cost and coverage concerns. Health Policy and Clinical Practice/Original Research. Annals Of Emergency Medicine, 43, 567–573.
Kini, N. M., & Strait, R. T. (1998). Nonurgent use of the pediatric emergency department during the day. Pediatrics Emergency Care, 14(1), 19–21.
Laine, C., Lin, Y. T., Hauck, W. W., & Turner, B. J. (2005). Availability of medical care services in drug treatment clinics associated with lower repeated emergency department use. Medicinal Care, 43(10), 985–995.
Langland-Orban, B., Pracht, E., & Salyani, S. (2005). Uncompensated care provided by emergency physicians in Florida emergency departments. Health Care and Management Review, 30(4), 315–321.
Lindsberg, P. J., Happola, O., Kallela, M., Valanne, L., Kuisma, M., & Kaste, M. (2006). Door to thrombolysis: ER reorganization and reduced delays to acute stroke treatment. Neurology, 67(2), 334–336.
Lowe, R. A., Bindman, A. B., Ulrich, S. K., Norman, G., Scaletta, T. A., Keane, D., Washington, D., & Grumbach, K. (1994). Refusing care to emergency department of patients: Evaluation of published triage guidelines. Annals of Emergency Medicine, 23(2), 286–293.
Ly, N., & McCaig, L. F. (2002). National Hospital Ambulatory Medical Care Survey: 2000 outpatient department summary. Advance Data, 327, 1–27.
Magid, D. J., Koepsell, T. D., Every, N. R., Martin, J. S., Siscovick, D. S., Wagner, E. H., & Weaver, W. D. (1997). Absence of association between insurance copayements and delays in seeking emrgency care among patients with myocardial infarction. The New England Journal of Medicine, 336(34), 1722–1729.
Mark, A., & Hall, J. D. (2004). The impact and enforcement of prudent layperson laws. Health policy and clinical practice/original research. Annals of Emergency Medicine, 43, 558–566.
Marsden, J. (2000). An evaluation of the safety and effectiveness of telephone triage as a method of patient prioritization accident and emergency service. Journal of Advance Nutrition, 31(2), 401–409.
McCaig, L. F., & Burt, C. W. (2004). National Hospital Ambulatory Medical Care Survey: 2001 emergency department summary. Advance Data, 1–36.
McCaig, L. F., & Burt, C. W. (2003). National Hospital Ambulatory Medical Care Survey: 2001 Emergency Department Summary: Advance data from vital and health statistics. No. 335. Hyattsville, MD: US National Center for Health Statistics.
McCaig, L. F. (1994). National Hospital Ambulatory Medical Care Survey, 1992 Emergency Department Summary: Advance data from vital and health statistics. No. 245. Hyattsville, MD: US National Center for Health Statistics.
McConnell, K. J. (2005). What do health savings accounts mean for the emergency department? Annals of Emergency Medicine, 46(6), 536–540.
Meggs, W. J., Czaplijski, T., & Benson, N. (1999). Trends in emergency department utilization, 1988–1997. Academic Emergency Medicine, 6(10), 1030–1035.
Midttun, L., & Martinussen, P. E. (2006). Hospital waiting time in Norway: What is the role of organizational change? Scandinavian Journal of Public Health, 34(3), 439–446 (author reply 333).
Moody-Williams, J. D., Linzer, J., Stern, A., Wilkinson, J., & Athey, J. (1999). Twenty-four-hour access to emergency care for children in managed care. Annals of Emergency Medicine, 34(6), 761–767.
Murphy, A. W., Bury, G., Plunkett, P. K., Gibeny, D., Smith, M., Mullan, E., & Johnson, Z. (1996). Randomised controlled trial of general practitioner versus usual medical care in an urban accident and emergency department: Process, outcome and comparative cost. BMJ, 312(7039), 1135–1142.
Neely, K. W., & Norton, R. L. (1999). Survey of health maintenance organization instructions to members concerning emergency department and 911 use. Annals of Emergency Medicine, 34(1), 19–24.
Neely, K. W., Norton, R. L., & Schmidt, T. A. (1999). State insurance commissioner actions against health maintenance organizations for denial of emergency care. Prehospital Emergency Care, 3(1), 19–22.
O’Brien, G. M., Shapiro, M. J., & Woolard, R. W., et al. (1996). Inappropriate emergency department use: A comparison of three methodologies for identification. Academic Emergency Medicine, 3, 252–257.
O’Brien, G. M., Stein, M. D., Zierler, S., Shapiro, M., O’Sullivan, P., & Woolard, R. (1997). Use of the ED as a regular source of care: Associated factors beyond lack of health insurance. Annals of Emergency Medicine, 30(3), 286–291.
O’Grady, K. F., Manning, W. G., Newhouse, J. P., & Brook, R. H. (1985). The impact of cost sharing on emergency department use. The New England Journal of Medicne, 313(8), 484–490.
Parente, S. T., Feldman, R., & Christianson, J. B. (2004). Employee choice of consumer-driven health insurance in a multiplan, multiproduct setting. Health Services Research, 39, 1091–1112.
Pasic, J., Russo, J., & Roy-Byrne, P. (2005). High utilizers of psychiatric emergency services. Psychiatrics Services, 56(6), 678–684.
Pauley, T. R., Magee, M. J., & Cury, J. D. (1995). Pharmacy-managed, physician-directed asthma management program reduces emergency department visits. Annals of Pharmacotherapy, 29, 5–9.
Pearson, D. C., Jackson, L. A., Wagener, B., & Sarver, L. (1998). A comprehensive influenza campaign in a managed care setting. Center for Health Promotion, Group Health Cooperaive of uget Sound, Seattle, WA 98101, USA. Vaccine, 16(18), 1718–1721.
Piehl, M. D., Clemens, C. J., & Joines, J. D. (2000). “Narrowing the gap”: Decreasing emergency department use by children enrolled in the medicaid program by improving access to primary care. Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescence Medicine, 154(8), 791–795.
Powers, R. D. (1997). Medicaid managed care and the emergency department: The first one hundred days. Journal of Emergency Medicine, 15(3), 393–396.
Press, Ganey Associates. (1997). Research initiatives: Patient satisfaction and wait time in the ER. November, Available: www.pressganey.com. Accessed 30 March 1999.
Reed, M., Fung, V., Brand, R., Fireman, B., Newhouse, J. P., Selby, J. V., & HSU, J. (2005). Care-seeking behavior in response to emergency department copayments. Medicinal Care, 43(8), 810–816.
Rockett, I. R., Putnam, S. L., Jia, H., Chang, C. F., & Smith, G. S. (2005). Unmet substance abuse treatment need, health services utilization, and cost: A population-based emergency department study. Annals of Emergency Medicine, 45(2), 118–127.
Ross, M. A., Compton, S., Richardson, D., Jones, R., Nittis, T., & Wilson, A. (2003). The use and effectiveness of an emergency department observation unit for elderly patients. Annals Of Emergency Medicine, 41(5), 668–677.
Rupp, M. T., McCallian, D. J., & Sheth, K. K. (1997). Developing and marketing a community pharmacy-based asthma management program. T Am Pharm Assoc [Wash], NS 37(6), 694–699.
Schappert, S. M., & Burt, C. W. (2006). Ambulatory care visits to physician offices, hospital outpatient departments, and emergency departments: United States, 2001–02. Vital Health Statistics, 13(159), 1–66.
Schneider, S. M., Cobaugh, D. J., & Leahey, N. F. (1998). Gatekeepers: A missed opportunity for safe transport. Academic Emergency Medicine, 5(6), 587–592.
Seaberg, D. C., Stimler, F. E., & Wears, R. L. (2000). Effect of state legislation prohibiting denial of emergency department patient claims. Annals of Emergency Medicine, 35, 267–271.
Selby, J. V., Fireman, B. H., & Swain, B. E. (1996). Effect of a copayment on use of the emergency department in a health maintenance organization. The New England Journal of Medicne, 334(10), 635–641.
Shalala, D. (1994). Most emergency cases aren’t. The Washington Post.
Shapiro, M. F., Ware, J. E. Jr, & Sherbourne, C. D. (1986). Effects of cost sharing on seeking care for serious and minor symptoms: Results of a randomized controlled trial. Annals of Internal Medicine, 104, 246–251.
Shen, B. (1997). Trends and changing roles in emergency medicine. Healthcare Information Management, 11(2), 67–77.
Shesser, R., Holtermann, K., Smith, J., et al. (2000). Results of provider self-adjudication using the prudent layperson standard compared with the managed care organization’s emergency department claim review process. Annals of Emergency Medicine, 36, 212–218.
Soumerai, S. B., McLaughlin, T. J., Gurwitz, J. H., Pearson, S., Christiansen, C. L., Borbas, C., Morris, N., McLaughlin, B., Gao, X., & Ross-Degnan, D. (1999). Timeliness and quality of care for elderly patients with acute myocardial infarction under health maintenance organization vs fee-for-service insurance. Archives Internal Medicne, 159(17), 2013–2020.
Smith, G. P., II. (1998). Patient dumping: Implications for the elderly. Elder Law Journal, 6, 165.
Speck, S. K., Peyrot, M., & Hsiao, C. W. (2003). Insurance coverage and health care consumers’ use of emergency departments: Has managed care made a difference? Journal of Hospital Marketing and Public Relations, 15(1), 3–18.
Tintinalli, J. E. (2000). Analysis of insurance payment denial using the prudent layperson standard. Annals of Emergency Medicine, 35, 291–294.
Tollen, L. A., Ross, M. N., & Poor, S. (2004). Risk segmentation related to the offering of a consumer-directed health plan: A case study of Humana, Inc. Health Services and Research, 39, 1167–1188.
Toung, C., Meyer, T., Wrenn, K., Wright, S., Ishihara, K., Cross, M., Grubbs, R., Biddinger, P., & Penn, D. (1997). Access to emergency care under TennCare: Do patients understand the system? Annals of Emergency Medicine, 30(3), 281–285.
Tyrance, P. H., Himmelstein, D. U., & Woolhandler, S. (1996). US emergency department costs: No emergency. American Journal of Public Health, 86(1), 1527–1531.
US General Accounting Office. Hospital Emergency Departments. (2003). Crowded conditions vary among hospitals and communities. General Accounting Office, Washington, DC.
Warburton, N. R. (2005). Preliminary outcomes and cost-benefit analysis of a community hospital emergency department screening and referral program for patients aged 75 or more. IJHCQA, 18(6), 474–484.
Weber, E. J., Showstack, J. A., Hunt, K. A., Colby, D. C., & Callaham, M. L. (2005). Does lack of a usual source of care or health insurance increase the likelihood of an emergency department visit? Results of a national population-based study. Annals of Emergency Medicine, 45(1), 13–14.
Weiner, S. J., Vangeest, J. B., Abrams, R. I., Moswin, A., & Warnecke, R. (2006). Avoiding free care at all costs: A survey of uninsured patients choosing not to seek emergency services at an urban county hospital. Journal of Urban Health, 83(2), 244–252.
Weinkauf, D. J., & Kralj, B. (1998). Medical service provision and costs: Do walk-in clinics differ from other primary care delivery settings? canadian public policy. Analyse de Politiques, XXIV, 471–484.
Williams, R. M. (1996). The costs of visits to emergency departments. The New England Journal of Medicine, 334, 642–646.
Williamson, H. A., Rosenblatt, R. A., & Hart, L. G. (1992). Physician staffing of small rural hospital emergency departments: Rapid change and escalating costs. Journal of Rural Health, 8(3), 171–177.
Wofford, J., Schwartz, E., & Byrum, J. (1993). The role of emergency services in health care for the elderly: A review. Journal of Emergency Medicne, 11(3), 317–326.
Yealy, D. M., De Hart, D. A., & Ellis, G., et al. (1989). A survey of observation units in the United States. American Journal of Emergency Medicine, 7, 576–580.
Young, G. P., & Lowe, R. A. (1997). Adverse outcome of managed care gatekeeping. Academic Emergency Medicine, 4(12), 1129–1136.
Zautcke, J. L., Fraker, L. D., Hart, R. G., & Stevens, J. S. (1997). Denial of emergency department authorization of potentially high-risk patients by Managed Care. Journal of Emergency Medicine, 15(5), 605–609.
Zwanziger, J., Hosek, S., Polich, S., Sloss, E., & McCaffrey, D. (1998). Effect of a large managed care program on emergency department use: Results from the CHAMPUS reform initiative evaluation. Annals of Emergency Medicine, 31(6), 741–748.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Simonet, D. Cost Reduction Strategies for Emergency Services: Insurance Role, Practice Changes and Patients Accountability. Health Care Anal 17, 1–19 (2009). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10728-008-0081-0
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10728-008-0081-0