How to minimize inappropriate utilization of Accident and Emergency Departments: improve the validity of classifying the general practice cases amongst the A&E attendees
Section snippets
Background
Accident and Emergency (A&E) Departments are designed to handle cases of acute emergency. However, these departments have become frequently used venues for delivering primary care. Within Hong Kong this phenomenon is particularly acute and the continuing inappropriate attendance of non-urgent patients is considered a serious problem in terms of inefficient utilization of resources and reduced efficiency in the care of true emergent cases.
Studies have found that one-third to two-thirds of all
Sampling frame
The study was designed as a prospective investigation of a representative sample of visitors to four A&E Departments located across the four principle geographic regions of Hong Kong. A stratified, two-stage (randomly selection of visitation periods followed by random selection of patients within each selected period) sampling frame was used. Based on past utilization data, visitation periods were broken into 24 h blocks for each day of the year and then stratified according to peak (>+1 S.D.)
Results
A total of 2410 subjects were included in the validity analyses. The level of disagreement between the paired expert record reviewers (for determining the gold standard of urgency) was 5%. For these, the third reviewer always resulted in an agreement with one of the inconsistent paired reviewers, and also the principal investigator and project co-ordinator. For both nurses and patients, S, SP and PPV were derived for all practical collapsed options from their five-point urgency ratings.
The
Discussion
Although the selection of hospitals in this study was not random, the samples obtained from them were, and matched well with the age and sex distributions of the A&E population of visitors for the whole territory of Hong Kong [13]. As the study sampled a 1 year time period accounting for both high and low utilization periods, and as the four departments handled about 35% of all A&E visits annually in Hong Kong, we concluded that the results had some degree of generalisability to Hong Kong's A&E
Conclusion
The current operating system in Hong Kong for classifying urgency status into five levels by nurses can be used to derive a reasonably valid triage, even if weighting for incorrect decisions is taken into consideration. Provided a mechanism exists for additional screening for some borderline cases (such as semi-urgent and urgent 2 cases), a safe system appears possible for screening out non-urgent patients from A&E (i.e. referring them to the care by GPs).
In Hong Kong, over half of the A&E
Acknowledgements
The authors would like to thank you the staff of the A&E Departments of United Christian Hospital, Pamela Youde Nethersole Eastern Hospital, Yan Chai Hospital and Tun Mun Hospital for their kind co-operation and assistance in data collection. We also wish to thank Health Services Research Fund for the research grant in this study.
References (31)
- et al.
Primary care in accident and emergency and general practice: a comparison
Social Science and Medicine
(1992) - et al.
Refusing care to emergency department patients: evaluation of published triage guidelines
Annals of Emergency Medicine
(1994) - et al.
Triage of patients out of the emergency department: three-year experience
American Journal of Emergency Medicine
(1992) - et al.
Prospective identification and triage of nonemergency patients out of an emergency department: a 5 year study
Annals of Emergency Medicine
(1995) - et al.
Does a physician visual assessment change triage?
American Journal of Emergency Medicine
(1997) Management of minor medical problems and trauma: general practice or hospital?
Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine
(1982)- et al.
The use of the accident and emergency department
Archives of Emergency Medicine
(1987) - et al.
Patient use of a pediatric hospital casualty in the east end of London
Family Practice
(1987) - et al.
Choice of care for minor trauma: hospital or general practice?
Family Practice
(1987) - et al.
Patients attending an accident and emergency department for primary medical care
Family Practice
(1984)
Primary care: the old bugbear of accident and emergency services
British Journal of General Practice
Accident and emergency services and general practice-conflict or co-operation?
Family Practice
Accident department or general practice
British Medical Journal
Hospital and emergency department overcrowding
Annals of Emergency Medicine
Cited by (39)
Still looking in the wrong place: Literature-based evidence of why patients really attend an emergency department
2023, Socio-Economic Planning SciencesArtificial Neural Networks and risk stratification models in Emergency Departments: The policy maker's perspective
2016, Health PolicyCitation Excerpt :Finally, syncope adverse events are rare; thus, a large number of events are required to build a consistent statistical model if we take the current statistical tools into account. Obviously, the problem of the correct classification of patients in ED, and their successive hospital admission, is not only a clinical matter but also a management issue [6,7], with potential significant impacts on ED crowding [8]. Indeed, improving the management of syncope patients and their rate of admission to emergency departments could dramatically reduce costs and optimize the use of healthcare system resources [9,10].
Pediatric overtriage as a consequence of the tachycardia responses of children upon ED admission
2015, American Journal of Emergency MedicineCitation Excerpt :However, triage misclassifications, including overtriage and undertriage, may negatively affect a patient's medical status and the medical resources of the ED. Van der Wulp and van Stel [11] and Lee et al [12] have addressed the ED patient safety issues associated with undertriage due to validity problems in the pediatric triage systems. In contrast, many studies have demonstrated that overtriage is far more frequently observed than undertriage among pediatric patients, and studies had also reported that applying vital signs modifiers during triage level assignment may lead to the upgrading of pediatric urgency levels [4,13–16].
Healthcare providers attitudes and perceptions of 'inappropriate attendance' in the Emergency Department
2013, International Emergency NursingThe association between the availability of ambulatory care and non-emergency treatment in emergency medicine departments: A comprehensive and nationwide validation
2013, Health PolicyCitation Excerpt :During the last few decades, many countries have faced the problem of increasing numbers of patients seeking treatment at hospital emergency departments (EDs) [1,2]. The adverse effects of overcrowded EDs are well-documented, and various methods to alleviate such overcrowding have been proposed [3–10]. Improving access to primary care to reduce non-emergency visits to EDs may represent one solution to excessive ED overcrowding [1].
Factors related to patient satisfaction with hospital emergency services
2012, Gaceta Sanitaria
- 1
Present address: Department of Health Science, The Hong Kong Polytechnic University, Hong Kong.