Violent patients and the prehospital provider

doi:10.1016/S0196-0644(05)80106-4

Annals of Emergency Medicine

Volume 22, Issue 8, August 1993, Pages 1276-1279

https://doi.org/10.1016/S0196-0644(05)80106-4 Get rights and content

Study objectives:

To estimate the frequency of violence directed toward prehospital providers; to identify the methods used to manage violent patients in the prehospital setting; and to identify the educational, medical, and legal issues in the prehospital management of violent patients.

Design:

A convenient sample survey and a descriptive review of ambulance call reports from June to December 1991.

Setting:

The survey was distributed to registrants at the National Association of EMS Physicians in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, in June 1992. Ambulance call reports were reviewed for a metropolitan county with a service population of 60,000.

Interventions:

None.

Results:

Only about 50% of survey respondents reported having protocols for the management of violent patients. Law enforcement officers provided assistance in managing violent patients for 97% of respondents, and 81% reported that a violent patient who refused transport could be arrested. Injury to prehospital providers in the past year was reported by 67% of respondents. Although 67% reported some training in the management of violent patients, only 9% had training by law enforcement officers and only 25% thought that they were trained in assessing the scene for potential violence. Ambulance call report review identified an 0.8% incidence of violent episodes. Weapons were evident in 12% of violent encounters. Transport was refused by 18% of violent patients. In 9% of violent encounters, patients were hypoglycemic. No emergency medical technician injuries were reported for the study period.

Conclusion:

The potential for injury to prehospital providers from violent patients is probably widespread, and no mechanism for identifying injuries or exposure to violent patients currently exists. All systems should have protocols for managing violent patients and for restraint application. Educational sessions for self-defense and assessment of the scene for violence may be indicated.

References (4)

LavoieFW et al.
Emergency department violence in United States teaching hospitals
Ann Emerg Med
(1988)
PaneGA et al.
Aggression directed toward emergency department staff at a university teaching hospital
Ann Emerg Med
(1991)

There are more references available in the full text version of this article.

Cited by (48)

Physical restraint within the prehospital Emergency Medical Care Environment: A scoping review
2023, African Journal of Emergency Medicine
Psychomotor agitation and aggressive behaviour (AAB) have the potential to occur in any healthcare setting, including those in which Emergency Medical Services (EMS) operate. This scoping review aimed to examine the available literature on physical restraint of patients within the prehospital setting and to identify guidelines and their effectiveness, safety to patients and health care practitioners and strategies relating to physical restraint when used by EMS.
We performed our scoping review using the methodological framework described by Arksey and O'Malley augmented by that of Sucharew and Macaluso. Several steps guided the review process: identification of the research question, eligibility criteria, information sources (CINAHL, Medline, Cochrane and Scopus), search, selection and data collection, ethical approval, collation, summarizing and reporting on the results.
The population of interest, in this scoping review was prehospital physically restrained patients, however, there was a reduced research focus on this population in comparison to the larger emergency department.
The limitation of informed consent from incapacitated patients may relate to the lack of prospective real-world research from previous and future studies. Future research should focus on patient management, adverse events, practitioner risk, policy, and education within the prehospital setting.
Preventing EMS workplace violence: A mixed-methods analysis of insights from assaulted medics
2018, Injury
Citation Excerpt :
in Australia, paramedics have a higher injury and fatality rate than any other occupational group [7]. Violence and assaults are a significant component of those risks [8–15]. Risk of violent assault might be heightened because EMS personnel work in isolated and uncontrolled environments, are in contact with the public and people in distress, and are associated with possessing valuable or desirable items such as drugs, syringes/needles and expensive equipment [10,16,17].
To describe measures that assaulted EMS personnel believe will help prevent violence against EMS personnel.
This mixed- methods study includes a thematic analysis and directed content analysis of one survey question that asked the victims of workplace violence how the incident might have been prevented.
Of 1778 survey respondents, 633 reported being assaulted in the previous 12 months; 203 of them believed the incident could have been prevented and 193 of them (95%) answered this question. Six themes were identified using Haddon’s Matrix as a framework. The themes included: Human factors, including specialized training related to specific populations and de-escalation techniques as well as improved situational awareness; Equipment factors, such as restraint equipment and resources; and, Operational and environment factors, including advanced warning systems. Persons who could have prevented the violence were identified as police, self, other professionals, partners and dispatchers. Restraints and training were suggested as violence-prevention tools and methods
This is the first international study from the perspective of victimized EMS personnel, to report on ways that violence could be prevented. Ambulance agencies should consider these suggestions and work with researchers to evaluate risks at the agency level and to develop, implement and test interventions to reduce the risks of violence against EMS personnel. These teams should work together to both form an evidence-base for prevention and to publish findings so that EMS medical directors, administrators and professionals around the world can learn from each experience.
Paramedic student exposure to workplace violence during clinical placements – A cross-sectional study
2017, Nurse Education in Practice
Citation Excerpt :
To date there has been two studies within Australia that have investigated the exposure of paramedics to acts of workplace violence (WPV) and the effects the exposure has had on paramedics (Boyle et al., 2007; Brough, 2005). The literature covering paramedic exposure to WPV dates back to the early 1990s where a study from the U.S.A. by Tintinalli first described the issue (Tintinalli and McCoy, 1993). We will use the previous Australian studies into WPV as comparators due to a lack of international studies into paramedic student exposure to WPV.
Paramedic students are hesitant to formally report exposure to acts of workplace violence as they feel it may jeopardise their chance of getting a job. The objective of this study was to identify the type and number of workplace violence acts experienced by undergraduate paramedic students whilst on an ambulance clinical placement. This was a cross-sectional study using the Paramedic Workplace Violence Exposure Questionnaire to obtain student exposure to acts of workplace violence which occurred whilst on ambulance clinical placements. The survey response rate was 29.8%. The students’ average age was 24.1 years, median age of 23 years, range 18–47 years. There were 32.6% of students who were exposed to at least one act of workplace violence with 56% of these being females. Verbal abuse 18%, and intimidation 17% were the common acts of workplace violence students were exposed to. One female, a nursing/paramedic student, was exposed to sexual harassment on more than one occasion. The findings from this study suggest that paramedic students are exposed to similar rates of workplace violence as full time practising paramedics. Further research is required into workplace violence against students from all professions and what detrimental effect this may have on them.
The Ethics of Real-Time EMS Direction: Suggested Curricular Content
2018, Prehospital and Disaster Medicine
Canadian operational and emotional prehospital readiness for a tactical violence event
2010, Prehospital and Disaster Medicine
Paramedic occupational violence mitigation: A comprehensive systematic review of emergency service worker prevention strategies and experiences for use in prehospital care
2021, Occupational and Environmental Medicine

View all citing articles on Scopus

View full text

EMS/Brief reportViolent patients and the prehospital provider