Original contribution
Correlation between triage nurse and physician ordering of ED tests

https://doi.org/10.1016/S0735-6757(98)90057-2Get rights and content

Abstract

Triage nurse ordering of tests can reduce patient time in the emergency department. This benefit must be balanced with the extra expense and potential morbidity of unnecessary tests. This study examined whether triage nurse ordering of lab tests and X-rays correlated with physician ordering. In Phase I, a prospective study, triage nurses completed an order form for each patient triaged during randomly selected 2-hour blocks over a 3-week period. In Phase II, Phase I was repeated with test ordering guidelines derived from Phase I results. Correlations of nurse and physician orders were analyzed by kappa statistics and paired t tests. In Phase I, 176 patients were enrolled of a possible 204 (82%). In Phase II, 350 patients were enrolled of a possible 418 (84%). The percentage of nurse overordering of tests in Phase I was 35%; in Phase II, it was 34% (P NS). Kappa values were determined for blood testing (Phase I, 0.48; Phase II, 0.54 [P = .048]), for X-ray (Phase I, 0.68; Phase II, 0.65 [P = .523]), for urinalysis (Phase I, 0.76; Phase II, 0.67 [P = .338]), and for electrocardiogram (Phase I, 0.78; Phase II, 0.77 [P = .438]). The Improved lab correlation in Phase II resulted from the nurses ordering fewer tests (P = .046). Nurses deviated from the test ordering guidelines in 37% of patients. Triage nurse ordering of X-rays, electrocardiogram, and urinalysis has moderate to substantial correlation with physician ordering. Correlation of triage nurse and physician ordering of tests can be improved with the use of test ordering guidelines.

Cited by (28)

  • Ordering Characteristics Predictive of Noncontrast CT Head Positivity in the Emergency Department

    2023, Academic Radiology
    Citation Excerpt :

    It is important to note that we evaluated exam positivity between the groups as an attempted comparative measure of over/underutilization but recognize that in several clinical scenarios a “negative” noncontrast Head CT can acutely change patient management and therefore may not necessarily be a byproduct of over-utilization. Our data is relatively discordant with prior work demonstrating that NP/PAs in comparison to physicians order excessive imaging studies in the outpatient clinic setting as well as the Emergency Department (12-14). This difference may be explained by the fact that the noncontrast head CT is unique in comparison to the broader scope of imaging and serves to answer a specific subset of clinical questions which likely have a higher degree of clinical concordance between NP/PAs and physicians in the ED setting.

  • Triage Nurse-Ordered Testing in the Emergency Department Setting: A Review of the Literature for the Clinician

    2021, Journal of Emergency Medicine
    Citation Excerpt :

    All three studies found reasonably good correlation between physicians and triage nurse-ordered imaging protocols, with 10.9% to 12.9% disagreement in two studies and a kappa of 0.65 to 0.68 in the third (11,17,18). One study analyzed the correlation between physician and triage nurse-ordered laboratory protocols, demonstrating a moderate correlation for laboratory studies (k = 0.48 to 0.54) (17). The problem of “overcrowding” in EDs continues to grow, with deleterious effects on the quality of care.

  • Experimental design and simulation applied to a paediatric emergency department: A case study

    2019, Computers and Industrial Engineering
    Citation Excerpt :

    First, ED managers and physicians tend to be sceptical about the appropriateness of allowing nurses to prescribe, and second, parents tend to press for a physician’s assessment before submitting their children to tests they perceive as painful or harmful (e.g. blood tests, X-rays). However, evidence from general EDs (Fry, 2001; Lee et al., 1996; Seaberg & Macleod, 1998) suggests that nurses’ prescriptions do not differ significantly from those of physicians. Given that complementary examinations such as lab tests and radiology exams strongly determine patient LOS (Gardner, Sarkar, Maselli, & Gonzales, 2007), allowing a nurse to prescribe such tests early in the process (i.e. during triage) seems a promising way of reducing LOS and rationalising the utilisation of consultation rooms and physicians.

  • Registered nurse scope of practice and ED complaint-specific protocols

    2013, Journal of Emergency Nursing
    Citation Excerpt :

    Likewise, the nurse may select a different set of orders from within an abdominal pain protocol for an elderly man with alcoholism who has upper right quadrant abdominal pain than for a sexually active, otherwise healthy, young female patient with pelvic pain. However, studies on the use of CSPs in the emergency department either do not outline the training offered, relay the training as a brief (1-hour) site-specific orientation, or assume that knowledge and skills are acquired through practice experience.3,4,18-20 Development of a standardized education program, modeled after Emergency Severity Index training,33 with documentation of individual RN knowledge, skill, and competency is indicated for states where CSPs may be allowed in the RN’s scope of practice.26

  • Optimizing Emergency Department Front-End Operations

    2010, Annals of Emergency Medicine
    Citation Excerpt :

    Protocols for medication administration (eg, oral analgesia for pain35) ordering of imaging studies (eg, radiograph for ankle injury),33,34 institution of elopement precautions,36 and initial management for disease-specific states (eg, pneumonia37) have been studied. Before the implementation of advanced triage protocol, one institution recorded only a 41% agreement between physician-directed test ordering and tests ordered by a triage nurse, with notable nurse overordering (35%) and underordering (37%) compared with that of sample physicians (class II).32 Implementation of advanced triage protocol improved the correlation between triage nurse and physician test ordering to 57% (P=.0042).

View all citing articles on Scopus

Supported by the Emergency Medicine Association of Pittsburgh.

Presented at the American College of Emergency Physicians Scientific Assembly, February 1995, San Francisco, CA, and the Pennsylvania Chapter of the American College of Emergency Physicians Annual Scientific Meeting, April 1993, Harrisburg, PA.

View full text